first off, do you mean 75gpD or gpH?
i've never seen one rated for 75 gallons per hour, only day...
i would start by asking what is the incomming water pressure.
there are several things that could cause it, but thats where i would start..
i have also read about some that have some kind of output inhancing devices on them, i dont remember what they were calling them, but it was like an afterthought pump, meaning that it would increase the filtered output and decrease the "waste" output.....
oh, and one other thing that might make a diff, are you measuring the parameters of the output of the old one compared to the new one? if for example, the new one was letting more stuff through, and thus would allow more flow through, it wouldnt be as good of a filter, but it would look(without testing) that it was producing more(even tho its of a lesser quality)
also, if your old one was only putting out (and i'm assuming here when you say a barrel, we're talking about roughly 55 gallons) that the old unit may have been clogged, or may be messed up...
hard to say for sure from here and without more details.