lilduud
Reefing newb
ya know i hate to bring this up again but this is one of the few fish i want in my 55...
i was speaking to two different guys on two separate occasions about keeping a purple tang in a 55. both of them said that they had done the exact thing more than once with great success as long as the tank has length... well my tank is four feet which is the length of the standard 90...
oh and before you say "your lfs is just trying to sell you things" well they do not carry purple tangs and they were encouraging me to use live aquaria.
i already know the arguments i just want to know has anyone ever had a purple tang in a 55 and if so i would like to hear how it went for the, because im running across more and more people who have done this successfully and who think i will have no problem with it. plus ive seen soooo many happy yellow tangs in 50 gallon tanks so how are they "100 gallon fish".... i guess the only reason im bringing all this up again is because ive never seen an unhappy tang even in supposedly awful living conditions [in terms of water volume]
PLEASE GIVE ME STORIES... even if its.. 'i had a tang and it went nuts and died because it was in a 55'... then at least i have some conflicting evidence
i was speaking to two different guys on two separate occasions about keeping a purple tang in a 55. both of them said that they had done the exact thing more than once with great success as long as the tank has length... well my tank is four feet which is the length of the standard 90...
oh and before you say "your lfs is just trying to sell you things" well they do not carry purple tangs and they were encouraging me to use live aquaria.
i already know the arguments i just want to know has anyone ever had a purple tang in a 55 and if so i would like to hear how it went for the, because im running across more and more people who have done this successfully and who think i will have no problem with it. plus ive seen soooo many happy yellow tangs in 50 gallon tanks so how are they "100 gallon fish".... i guess the only reason im bringing all this up again is because ive never seen an unhappy tang even in supposedly awful living conditions [in terms of water volume]
PLEASE GIVE ME STORIES... even if its.. 'i had a tang and it went nuts and died because it was in a 55'... then at least i have some conflicting evidence