Actually, the new one is the pink tipped frogspawn. After getting them side by side, I was more convinced that the first one I bought (this one pictured) was not a frogspawn. To be fair, the store didn't have it labeled and I said "I'd like that frogspawn". The guy might have been thinking, that's obviously a torch coral, lady! LOL
But it also seems to be developing some color it didn't have when I brought it home, the yellow-orange color you can see developing in the tentacles.
Thanks for the opinions, all :D