Cheato is that green spaghetti looking alge that absorbs all that stuff you see in your tests. Nitrate, phosphate, stuff like that. Do you have hair algae in the tank? What you are seeing is waste products, like a sewer, poop, uneaten food, waste, dead critters. What kind of clean up crew do you have? When you do a water change do you suck the water off the bottom of the tank to try and remove the dirt? Do you have good water flow? Powerheads? You should drop those levels with a water change pretty fast. I would test the fresh water from your fish store. Where do you get your water?